Charging vs Fuel, Taxes & Depreciation
Comparing an auto lease against buying requires separating monthly cash flow from net wealth after depreciation. Because a 36-month lease only funds the portion of a vehicle expected to depreciate over three years (plus finance rent and dealer fees), monthly lease payments almost always look dramatically lower than a 60-month loan payment. However, at month 36 the lessee walks away with zero asset equity, whereas the buyer owns a used vehicle worth 50% to 65% of original MSRP minus the remaining loan payoff. In states that tax only the monthly lease payment rather than the full vehicle purchase price, leasing also offers a partial upfront sales-tax deferral.
In normal market conditions, buying a reliable vehicle with strong 3-year resale retention (such as popular Japanese crossovers or trucks retaining 60% to 64% value) easily beats leasing financially, particularly if you keep driving the car payment-free in years six through ten. Depreciation is steepest in the first 36 months and flattens sharply afterward, meaning long-term owners amortize that initial drop across a decade. Also keep in mind lease acquisition fees ($695 to $995 upfront) and turn-in disposition fees ($395 to $595 at lease end), which rarely show up in advertised monthly teaser quotes.
Two specific market exceptions tilt the 36-month math back toward leasing. First, heavily incentivized EV leases that pass through commercial tax credits, inflated residual guarantees, or subsidized sub-2% money factors often produce effective 3-year costs lower than buying and absorbing steep real-world EV depreciation. Second, high-depreciation luxury sedans and European SUVs that drop to 44% to 48% of sticker price within three years sometimes cost less to lease than to finance and resell privately, while keeping the owner under full factory bumper-to-bumper warranty for the entire holding window.
Before Signing a Lease or Auto Finance Sheet
- Avoid putting large cash down on a lease: if the car is totaled or stolen in month three, lease down payments are typically forfeited.
- Check the lease money factor (multiply by 2,400 to convert to APR) and acquisition/disposition fees ($650 to $995 each).
- Confirm realistic annual miles (10k, 12k, or 15k) before signing, since lease excess mileage penalties run $0.20 to $0.35 per mile.
EV & Auto Ownership FAQ
Unlike a purchase loan where down payment builds equity in an asset you own, a lease down payment merely prepays part of your 36-month rent. If the leased vehicle is totaled in an accident, gap insurance settles the lessor's balance and your upfront cash down is rarely recovered.
Multiply the quoted money factor (for example, 0.00250) by 2,400 to approximate the equivalent annual percentage rate (0.00250 x 2,400 = 6.0% APR).
Yes, if your vehicle's actual market resale value at month 36 exceeds the contractual residual buyout price locked into your original lease agreement, purchasing it or trading that positive equity toward your next vehicle captures instant value.
Standard lease contracts penalize excess miles at $0.20 to $0.35 per mile upon turn-in. Driving 5,000 miles over your 36-month cap adds $1,000 to $1,750 in turn-in fees unless you buy out the lease instead or prepay discounted extra miles when signing your original contract.